When patients file medical malpractice lawsuits, doctors and hospitals rarely accept responsibility without a fight. Instead, they often use a variety of legal defenses to challenge the claims. If you’re thinking about pursuing a malpractice case, it’s important to understand these strategies so you know what to expect.
1. The Standard of Care Was Met
One of the most common defenses is claiming that the doctor acted within the accepted medical standard of care.
-
Medicine isn’t always exact, and different doctors may choose different treatment methods.
-
If the defense can show that another reasonable doctor would have acted the same way, the malpractice claim may fail.
👉 Example: A doctor chooses one treatment method over another, and both are medically accepted.
2. The Injury Was Not Caused by the Doctor
Even if an error occurred, doctors may argue that the injury was not directly caused by their actions.
-
They may claim the patient’s condition would have worsened regardless of treatment.
-
Or they may argue that complications arose naturally and were not preventable.
👉 Example: A patient develops an infection after surgery, but the defense argues it was due to the patient’s own health condition, not negligence.
3. Contributory or Comparative Negligence
In some cases, the defense may argue that the patient was partly responsible for their own harm.
-
Not following medical advice.
-
Failing to take prescribed medications.
-
Ignoring follow-up appointments.
Depending on state laws, if a patient is found partly at fault, their compensation may be reduced—or they may not be able to recover damages at all.
4. The Statute of Limitations Has Expired
Every state has strict deadlines for filing malpractice lawsuits, often 1–3 years after the incident.
-
If a patient files too late, the defense can use this as a complete shield against the claim.
-
This is why timely legal action is critical.
5. Assumption of Risk
Sometimes, doctors argue that the patient knew the risks before undergoing treatment or surgery.
-
If the patient signed an informed consent form, the defense may say the complications were a known possibility.
-
However, this defense does not excuse outright negligence or errors.
6. The “Good Samaritan” Defense
In emergencies, some states protect doctors under Good Samaritan laws.
-
If a doctor provides aid during a crisis outside a hospital setting, they may be shielded from malpractice liability.
-
This defense is less common but can arise in urgent situations.
Why These Defenses Matter
These defenses show why malpractice cases are rarely straightforward. Hospitals and insurance companies often have teams of lawyers working to deny claims.
-
Patients need strong medical evidence.
-
Expert witnesses are usually required.
-
Skilled attorneys play a crucial role in countering these defenses.
Final Thoughts
If you’re pursuing a medical malpractice case, expect the defense to challenge every part of your claim. They may argue the standard of care was met, the injury wasn’t caused by negligence, or that the case was filed too late.
👉 The key to success lies in building a solid case with strong evidence and expert testimony. If you believe you’ve been a victim, don’t delay—consult a medical malpractice lawyer who understands these defenses and knows how to fight them.
0 Comments